The internet has struck gold again, and this time it’s all thanks to Martin Scorsese’s unexpected talent for deciphering his own films from cryptic Letterboxd reviews. But here’s where it gets fascinating: the legendary director, known for his cinematic masterpieces, can somehow navigate the bizarre world of two-sentence film critiques with surprising accuracy. If you’ve ever stumbled upon The Martin And Francesca Scorsese Comedy Hour (https://www.avclub.com/martin-scorsese-tricked-going-viral-tiktok-1851028203), you’re already familiar with the dynamic: Francesca, his daughter, playfully drags her dad into the chaotic realm of modern internet film culture, while Scorsese grumbles good-naturedly, creating a hilarious blend of generational humor, his signature wit, and heartwarming father-daughter banter. It’s been a while since their last viral moment, so their latest escapade—featuring Scorsese tackling the oddly specific language of Letterboxd reviews—was a delightful surprise.
In a recent Instagram post, the duo, promoting Apple TV+’s new five-part docuseries (https://www.avclub.com/apple-tv-mr-scorsese-docuseries-superb-revealing) about Scorsese’s life and career, showcased his ability to match Letterboxd reviews to his films. While Scorsese himself uses the platform more as a film diary than a review battleground, he impressively guessed which of his movies inspired reviews written in that uniquely Letterboxd tone. (We’re pretty sure he intuited that “Ratatouille would have thrived in this environment” was a Goodfellas reference, but he instantly recognized Killers of the Flower Moon and The Departed.)
And this is the part most people miss: the charm isn’t just in Scorsese’s guesses—it’s in his endearingly old-school reactions. His confusion over “Stan Twitter” is pure gold, and his grumpy yet lovable dad energy shines when he protests a Letterboxd user labeling The Age of Innocence “for the girls.” “That’s for everyone!” he declares, while Francesca laughs uncontrollably. It’s a reminder that even cinematic icons can be hilariously out of touch—and that’s what makes it so endearing.
Controversial take alert: Is Letterboxd’s review culture too niche, or is it a refreshing evolution of film critique? And does Scorsese’s ability to decode these reviews prove he’s more in tune with modern audiences than we think? Let’s debate in the comments. Meanwhile, if you haven’t already, check out Mr. Scorsese on Apple TV+ for a deeper dive into the man behind the memes.
